Category Archives: Mail Bag

An archive of my responses to members questions, comments and suggestions.

New Breakout Tracker Is Stunning! Some Suggestions….

Question:

You new breakout web page is stunning. I like the design and the idea of multiple pages which gets rid of the clutter. With that said, I have two questions:
  • With so many pages of stocks is there any way to "find" a specific stock, i.e., if I use the Find Command (Ctrl-F) on page 1 will it wander through all the pages to find it for me? As opposed to paging through all the pages manually.
  • Hiding the comments section is a nice touch. However, I copy and paste these great comments into a stock tracking software (Checklist Investor) so that all the relevant informational pieces from various sources are in one place for a specific stock. Is there any way to copy these comments? I tried right clicking on the comments logo but that didn’t have any options that copied the info.

My Response:

I’m glad you like the new breakout tracker.. I am very pleased with the way it turned out.   I hadn’t thought of what you are suggesting and glad that you did – i’m always interested in the ways that members use the service.  The most exciting part of the new tracker is the multitude of ways analyze the data.. ie. performance of stocks w/ specific ranking, avg buy volume for industries as a whole, the % of the time these breakouts reach a 20% gain vs. the % of time they hit an 8% loss, etc.  This is where the service is headed.  The overall vision is to create analytics page with all kinds of this informative info… in order to hone in on the absolute best strategy for profiting from the market.
 
Regarding your specific suggestions I will discuss them with my programmer in the coming days.  These should be fairly easy to implement.  The notes are kept in a database and it should be fairly easy to pull them out into a .CSV Excel.  What I could do is make the entire watchlist available for download as an Excel file so members can use the data in any they want to. 
[update: these features have been implemented]

Finding Opportunities, Executing the Trade (in a nutshell)

Question:

Probably the most difficult thing I have found about investing is catching
the breakouts as they are happening.  Here’s what I would find hellpful:

1.  I would like to get a glimpse into your trading room and see what it is
you are watching & doing to catch breakouts. Is there some way you could
write an article telling us in simple language — here’s how I start my day,
here’s what I watch thoughout the day, here’s what’s on my computer screen
thoughout the day,  here’s the thought process I’m going through once I spot
a possible breakout and here’s when I pull the trigger.   Maybe write an
article about a typical trading where you talk us through your day.

Its seems that there are 3 things you have to watch throughout the day to
catch a breakout as it is happening: 1) price as it approaches the pivot
point 2) A chart showing daily volume (not sure if daily or intraday, say 5
minute would be best) and 3) Volume % increase.  Are these 3 things
primarily what you are watching?  What is it you have on your screen?

I’ve thought it out and it seems like I need a 2 monitor setup to do this: 1
monitor with real time quotes on the hottest of the hot stocks plus charts
on stocks that look like the price is approaching the pivot point that day
and a second monitor where you could watch volume % increase on those
stocks.  This of course is now going to be available at SelfInvestors.com. 
By watching the price, the chart & the volume –you should be able to catch
the breakout.  Is this how you do it?  If not –how.  Could you please write
an artice on this.  I’m tired of missing breakouts & then trying to get in a
stock that’s now 3, 4 or 5% past the pivot point!!! I want to learn how to
nail the breakout!

Well, I better get to work.  I look forward to a long and profitable
relationship!  Your service is awesome!

My Response:

So, what’s my process in seeking a quality stock and executing a purchase at the breakout…
The process really starts after the market close the day before…looking at the overall health of the market, pinpointing sectors and industries leading the market, then finding the best stocks within those sectors and industries.  The design and layout of SelfInvestors is a reflection of the way I go about investing in the markets.  In fact I use the website just as you might as a member – and it has allowed me to become a much more disciplined and profitable investor.  The website has truly refined my strategy and to be honest I’m still refining that strategy every day.  Hence, the changes in the service.  I am constantly thinking about how I can make it easier to profit from the market and the tools you see now are just the beginning.  After all, the site is only 4 months old! It’s amazing to think about the process that has been made in that amount of time.. I’ve got many new features planned in the coming months!
 
Ok, enough rambling.  You asked specifically about getting in at the breakout.  I can tell you that this is the most asked question I get from members and I can understand why.  Very few have the ability to sit at their computers all day and watch the markets… even if you did, I think it’s a bad idea.  Before I get into how I go about buying the breakout and how you can best catch the breakout let me just add here how I responded to this question in the past:
See My Previous Response Here
Ok, John..on to your specific situation.   You are able to spend a couple minutes watching a stock as it approaches the pivot from what it sounds like.  I think we are in similar situations.  I certainly don’t have the time to watch real time price moves all day long either and wouldn’t recommend it if you could.  It leads to irrational decisions and sloppy trading.  In a nutshell, here’s the process I use (I like you’re idea of an article and will try and find the time in the next couple weeks to put together a more detailed approach .. how I go about using the tools at SelfInvestors and taking that info to execution of a purchase)

 
Night Before
1. Putting the daily report together keeps me focused on the health of the market and keeps me clued in to sector and industry group rotations
2.  I’ll sort by Total Rank and focus on stocks that are highly ranked and within an industry that is performing well (this sort will most likely bring up all of the "Hot" stocks as well)
3. Make a list of these stocks and take a closer look.. Is the base quiet? Does buy volume exceed sell volume? How close is the stock to breaking out? I will probably add another column to the Breakout Tracker soon – % from the pivot.. this way you can sort and get a list of stocks of stocks that are closest to breakout.  So you can be sure to focus on them the next day.
4. Once you have your list of a few stocks, you’ll enter them into a real time watchlist.   I use TCNet Platinum for this.
5. Make sure you know what the average hourly volume is for each stock as well as it’s pivot point and any support/resistance levels (keep track of this in a log book).  Keep in mind that the Breakout Tracker uses delayed quotes and is refreshed every 15 minutes.  You’ll need a real time look at volume levels when purchasing a breakout. 
 
Once you’ve got your hourly volume avg (Total avg volume/ 6.5 hrs in trading day) and your pivot point, you’ll want to set an alert (which you should be able to set through your broker or whatever trackig software you use) below the pivot point price. say 3-5% or so.  Is the stock still acting quiet?  Set another alert a bit closer.  You’ll know when the stock is getting ready to run because the volume will pick up significantly and you’ll see price shoot up, pull back quite a bit, shuffle back and forth and then take off.  This is the volatility and big volume at the breakout.  Once the stock hits the pivot, execute the trade without hesitation.  Believe in your research.. or mine:} and roll with it.  If you are wrong… and you will be some of the time, cut your loss.  If you’ll notice in the porftolio I am wrong more than I am right, but my average gain is more than double my loss for every trade I make.  All it takes is a few big winners and that’s the goal with my approach.  You must accept the fact that you may be wrong 50% of the time or even more.
  
Well, gotta run.. it’s been a long day.  I realize I may have rambled here.. maybe even to the point of incoherency. Please let me know if you have any further questions and thanks for being a part of SelfInvestors.. have a nice weekend!

Volume Questions: How to Determine If Breakout Volume is Sufficient & Sell Volume

Question:

On a breakout during the day, how do you determine if the volume is sufficient? Do you just extrapolate the breakout volume from the time of the breakout and compare it to the 50 dma of the stock’s volume? WOM likes to see a 50% volume increase on breakout. Do you use a minimum percent volume over the average? 

Another volume question. On a pull-back from a breakout, I assume you want the volume to decrease. What is your take on a pullback with an increasing volume? Again, is there a rule-of-thumb for determining an optimal volume decrease for buying in at a pullback? 

My Response:

For real time volume levels, you can compare volume to the average for any time during the day.. i discuss this in the tutorial section on buying.  Take the 50 day average and divide by 6.5 (hrs in trading day).  That gives you the hourly average volume which is also listed in the breakouts watchlist.  If the stock breaks out at 8:30AM take the hourly average and Multiply by two to get the average at that point in the trading day.  Compare this number to the trading volume of the stock.  On a delayed basis the percentage change from the average volume is published every 15 min. for each stock in the Breakout Tracker.
 
Regarding selling volume on an intraday basis you can use the method above to see if volume is below average at that point in the trading day.  To see the trend over several days or weeks, just pull up a chart (stockcharts.com is great) and look at the red volume bars of the stock.  Are they getting shorter as the stock declines?  You won’t always see a good decrease in volume.. what’s important is that selling volume isn’t surging.  On pullbacks, watching to see if it finds support at key levels is often just as, if not more important than the volume level..  Of course nothing is 100% certain in the stock market.  You use this information to gauge probability of success.  The key to becoming a good chart reader is to just start looking at the charts.  After you’ve looked at thousands of charts, you will notice certain trends and patterns emerge. 

Overhead Supply

Question:

When you buy a breakout such as you did with EASI, what are your concerns about overhead supply? I noticed this stock will be hitting the December high of 61.93 fairly soon. How will you handle this?

My Response:

Overhead supply is of some concern, but not much in this case.  The December high is the all time high, which may offer some resistance in the form of another handle like formation (pull back on lighter volume).  Much more important of a resistance level is 60.  Multiples of 5 and 10 are often sources of resistance for higher priced stocks.  For example, investors rarely say sell my position when it hits 61.93.  They will set a sell or tell the broker to sell at 60.  This is exactly what we are seeing now.  Notice I chose a breakout point for this stock quite low in the right side?  Sometimes it’s a good idea to purchase lower in the right side, because your purchase point is much closer to major support which allows you to stay in the stock longer w/out getting stopped out of the position.  How do you know which stocks to purchase lower in the in the right side?  Depends on volume, price action and instinct (based on viewing many charts)… this is where experience comes into play

Easing Into Position During Market Uncertainty

Question:

I notice that all your recent buys have been taken with a half position. Is this standard procedure for you is are you doing it because of the uncertain and volatile market? For adding on to a rising buy, some people advocate adding on 50% of the original buy with the next buy at 25% of the original and so on. Does this make sense to you?

My Response:

Not standard procedure, but procedure in an uncertain market.  Much of that uncertainty was removed with the breakout of yesterday.  Any positions opened at this point will be full positions.  Please keep in mind that there are great stocks that won’t be purchased for the SelfInvestors.com.. i simply just don’t have the time to cover them all.  I try to pick a couple here and there to give members an idea of real world, real time implementation of how a portfolio is run.

I Can’t Watch the Market During the Trading Day, How Can I Avoid Missing Opportunities?

Question:

My job prohibits me from any other role than being an end-of-the-day trader. Consequently, I often miss buy points when a stock explodes past the appropriate buy range (pivot + 5%). In a strong bull market I can stretch my buy window to +10%. In this sideways market, however, I am wondering if I should put a buy stop near promising prospects even though I understand that I cannot possibly predict which ones will blow and which ones will continue to consolidate. A buy stop with a Good-Till-Cancel might ameliorate this dilemma somewhat. Of course, I could also wait for a pullback but with this market many good breakouts are falling back below the pivot. Do you have any thoughts on this? This question becomes more interesting as I am watching EASI being absent from my portfolio.

My Response:

Another member was asking me about this recently.  I’m going to copy here how I replied to him, then I’ll add some more comments.
 
It’s a great question.  There are a few things that you can do..
1.  Placing a buy stop around the pivot point is not such a bad idea. .. the
only problem with this is that you don’t have the luxury of avoiding a
purchase if the buying volume is not there.  Being able to watch the stock
move in real time is a major advantage and often times you anticipate a
large move in stock by looking at the volatility around the pivot point.
Unfortunately, not many have the luxury of watching these breakouts in real
time.  If you use the buy stop and find that the stock is not breaking out
successfully, you can always sell the next day.

2. If you have a cell phone that allows you to receive emails, you can
receive these alerts as they happen and put in a call to your broker or make
an online trade at a break in work or on your lunch break provided the stock
is still within the 5% range.

3. Another strategy is avoiding the initial breakout altogether and waiting
for a pullback to the buy point range (half of all stocks will come back the
buy point before resuming their advance).  If you take a look at the
Breakouts area , all of the previous breakouts are listed.  There are some
good buys there (i have not had time to rank those yet, but plan to do so
soon).  Companies like Robert Half (RHI), Kensey (KNSY) I believe are still
in a "buyable range" which is 5% from the breakpoint.  Also, if you take a
look at the recent additions to the portfolio, all are still in a buyable
range.  However, it’s important to buy as close to the pivot as possible.

The reason for implementing the ranking system is to keep investors focused
on the very best breakouts with just seconds a day… there are a ton of
stocks out there and it only makes since to hold 5-10 at a time, so why not
own the best.  Since your capital is limited I would focus on only the best,
which are generally stocks purchased for this portfolio.   I am also
considering adding a  risk rank for each breakout stock to give investors
another tool for buying what’s best for their circumstances.   If there is
anything else you’d like to see in this area, please let me know.

 
I would never recommend chasing a stock that is 10% past it’s pivot point. 
The only time this is a good idea is when a breakout stock returns to the 50 DMA
and bounces (ok, to add shares here).  But this strategy requires you to watch
the stock carefully in real time, so it doesn’t suit your situation very well.
 
Here’s a strategy that I would use.  For the absolute best candidates, you may want
to try the buy stop method.  The only problem I see with this is that your order will get filled far
away from the buy stop, especially if the stock is really running.  So, you’ll want to put in a limit
.
 
The other strategy is to keep an eye on past breakouts with the Breakout Tracker.  Which stocks
are highest ranked in all categories. Do a sort by overall rating, then check the gain from breakout.. is it
within 5% of breakout? Is it pulling back on light volume?  Is it finding support at key areas?
If so, pull the trigger provided the market is cooperating.  As far as EASI goes, the stock will undoubtedly pull
back to an acceptable buy range, so keep an eye on it.
 
Hope this helps.. let me know if you have further questions. 

Best Way to Purchase Stocks

Question (from Vernon K):

I am a preimum member and since I usually work during the day I come home to find your email about purchases in the SelfInvestor.com Featured Portfolio. I would like to follow along with some of these picks, but find that many of these stocks have risen from the optimal breakout point. I could place stop buy orders with my broker for the breakout stocks that haven’t been purchased yet, but that seems like over kill and I don’t have enough captial to buy them all. Are there any recommendations that you can give so I make the purchase closer to the breakout price since I would have 1 market day delay in the purchase? How far past the breakout price is safe for purchasing? Thanks.

My Answer:

It’s a great question. There are a few things that you can do.. 1. Placing a buy stop around the pivot point is not such a bad idea. .. the only problem with this is that you don’t have the luxury of avoiding a purchase if the buying volume is not there. Being able to watch the stock move in real time is a major advantage and often times you anticipate a large move in stock by looking at the volatility around the pivot point. Unfortunately, not many have the luxury of watching these breakouts in real time. If you use the buy stop and find that the stock is not breaking out successfully, you can always sell the next day. 2. If you have a cell phone that allows you to receive emails, you can receive these alerts as they happen and put in a call to your broker or make an online trade at a break in work or on your lunch break provided the stock is still within the 5% range. 3. Another strategy is avoiding the initial breakout altogether and waiting for a pullback to the buy point range (half of all stocks will come back the buy point before resuming their advance). If you take a look at the Breakouts area , all of the previous breakouts are listed. There are some good buys there (i have not had time to rank those yet, but plan to do so soon). Companies like Robert Half (RHI), Kensey (KNSY) I believe are still in a "buyable range" which is 5% from the breakpoint. Also, if you take a look at the recent additions to the portfolio, all are still in a buyable range. However, it’s important to buy as close to the pivot as possible. The reason for implementing the ranking system is to keep investors focused on the very best breakouts with just seconds a day… there are a ton of stocks out there and it only makes since to hold 5-10 at a time, so why not own the best. Since your capital is limited I would focus on only the best, which are generally stocks purchased for this portfolio. I am also considering adding a risk rank for each breakout stock to give investors another tool for buying what’s best for their circumstances. If there is anything else you’d like to see in this area, please let me know.  

A Bit About Me

Question:

I just read your reports for the 3 stocks you sent me.  You really have
a gift for analyzing stocks. I can’t believe how easily you analyze
them.  I am so jealous.  How long have you been doing this?  I keep
learning and learning.  Going back to my books and looking up patterns,
etc.. I am so happy owning SAFM especially after seeing what you have to
say.  The insider selling was a concern to me and that is why I held out
buying for so long.  I know everyone has different reasons for selling.
I read on the yahoo message board for SAFM that the company plans on
opening a new processing facility in GA.  It should be announced in the
short term.  It is supposed to increase production by 20%.  So once that
is announce publicly it should help the stock even more. 

I hope you are doing well with the site and that you are making money in
the market.  I wish only good things for you.  You deserve them!

My Response:

thanks for the kind words!  I’m relatively young.. haven’t quite reached my
30th birthday!  Since I don’t have a family yet, I’m able to spend more time
learning about the market.  It was during my first job out of college that I
realized I didn’t ever want to work for anyone but myself.  I worked for a
fairly large corporation and wasn’t compensated for the work I put it in.. I
was just a number and wasn’t compensated by performance, but by job title.
So I left.  Went back to school to get certified as a Microsoft engineer
only to have the industry collapse.. definitely a low point in my life.
While all this was going on I was studying the markets whenever I could..
and realized it was the only way I wanted to earn a living.  To be able to
work anywhere in the world is very, very appealing to me!  For the last five
years, I’ve spent several hours a day seven days a week studying charts,
reading books, books and magazines.  I guess you could say I was fascinated
with the way the market works!     I was a math and chemistry major in
college, so have always been into numbers.  I studied psychology a bit too,
so the manipulation of prices based on human emotions seemed right up my
alley.  I haven’t looked back.  Every day I learn something new.. it never
gets old and I enjoy sharing my research with others.  The website is my
outlet.  None of my friends are investors or enjoy this kind of stuff, so I
need a place to get my thoughts out!!!  CANSLIM.net gave me a taste of that,
but I need more of a creative outlet… hence the site.  It’s been an
exciting journey and am looking forward to seeing where it leads.

My advice to you is study as many charts as you can.. you begin to see
certain volume and price patterns.  You probably have an idea now of the
kind of charts I look for.  Low volatility, quiet charts with decreasing
selling volume near major support areas.  If it’s a flat base, all the
better.  To be honest I place more emphasis on the technical side than I do
the fundamentals..probably 60/40 technical or so.  Anyway, I’m done
rambling.  Have a good day. 

Price Targets, For the Most Part.. Are Worthless

Question:

Do you have a target price technique that you use as a rule of thumb?

My Response:

I don’t believe in price targets..at least those based on the fundamentals which is what analysts use to come up with price targets.  The only time I’m able to guesstimate a price target are at areas of technical resistance.    For example, if I purchase a stock at $10/share, but the 52 week high is at $12/share I can reasonably assume that there will some resistance in the stock there and I’d call that a short term price target.    That might be an area where I take some profit.  I reevaluate my position in a stock every day or two.  I’ll continue to hold as long as it continues to look good.. whether that is one week or one year, it depends on the day to day action of the stock as well as the health of the overall market.   I wish analysts would quit trying to give price targets.. they’re worthless!